Category Archives: Technology

It’s not us, it’s you

Open-source  software and services like Linux, Firefox Web browser and Wikipedia are very famous. These are some well known examples of product development with the help of the community. This is a phenomenon that started purely as a community effort backed by a foundation or a non-profit organization. But the massive effect this has had over the past years made even the corporations with big bets on IP involve the customers in mass customization of their products. And this is not limited to high tech products anymore, even conventional products like t-shirts and shoes are getting co-designed by the customers. The open innovation wave is touching everything from food-flavors to music systems to video games. 

Let’s skim through a few examples to add value to what we are talking here. Slim devices is one of the favorites in open innovation. Slim devices has a community of music enthusiasts who help the small staff of in-house designers give shape to their next music player. The community is so strongly knit that sometimes its even hard to tell who is an outsider and who is a company employee. Some top contributors in the community have complete access to the designs and source of the Slim’s future releases.

Big names in the footwear industry are asking customers to help them design shoes. Customers can evaluate new designs, give feedback or even create totally new designs in a CEC-made-shoe project launched by the European Confederation of footwear industry. Famous Canadian shoe designer John Fluevog has also been soliciting ideas from the customers. Brand enthusiasts are encouraged to submit their own sketches for all kinds of shoes including leather boots, high-heeled dress shoes and sneakers. The submissions are posted on the company website and customers discuss and vote for the design leading to the best ones being manufactured by the company.

Start-ups like Zazzle.com are leading to an even more innovative open source development. Zazzle customizes all kind of merchandise for the customers. Customers can contribute their own designs at Zazzle or pick from one of the designs available in there. If other customers choose to get mechandize designed by a contributor, the contributor gets loyalty from the site. Zazzle is creating a massive community of designers who are using it as a platform to sell their design and add an additional avenue to their business.

Even food-flavors are customized to suite the customers’ taste. Frito-Lay customizes the taste of their chips in each geography based on the feedback from the customers. Same is the story with burgers at McDonald’s. So the taste of chips and burgers you will get in US will be considerably different when compared with the ones in Europe or Asia.

Involving customers in designing products is a real blessing for marketing. Marketing department in a company acts like the voice of the customers. They are the one who make sure customer requirements are fulfilled and the product has all they need. By involving customers in co-designing the products, the company is easing the job of the marketers. When customers call the shots, they generate an affinity with the company. This makes the task of marketing organization even easier because they get advocates in the form of these customers.

Product development also benefits a lot from customer involvement. They are able to tap in a lot of unexplored talent for almost negligible cost. In order to make sure there is good customer involvement, the company will have to create a good community experience and make the customer feel that they are welcome. The important thing to remember is that the company is in a way doing marketing and advertising all throughout the product development.

In a nutshell, I think involving customers in designing the products and services is like a win-win scenario for everyone. The customers get what they want and the company gets a lot of assistance in their marketing and product development. George Costanza claims that there can be no better break-off excuse than his invention – “It’s not you, it’s me”. In a (kind-of) similar fashion (though I don’t claim it as my invention :-)), I think there can be no better product out there than the one co-designed by its customers with the company stating loud and clear – “It’s not us, it’s you”! 

You got the solution, look for the problems

In a previous post titled One size doesn’t fit all, I mentioned about thermoplastic microspheres to adjust shoe size. I did a web search for thermoplastic microsphere and found that it has many other applications. In fact, DuPont is actively trying to research different places where they can use thermoplastic microspheres, along with adjusting shoe size for which it was primarily developed. The basic property of this material is it widens in width on applying heat, never to compress again. That means it can solve problem where you want to adjust the width and then keep that width constant. DuPont came up with some very interesting “problems” for which this is acting like a good solution. They are trying to use this as a solution for cancerous tumors in blood vessels. Thermoplastic microspheres can be injected in blood vessels having cancerous tumors, it will expand on applying heat and the tumor will compress and die (this is in clinical tests at this time). Another interesting use of this material is to inject it in wood floors to act like a foaming agent. Yet another use of it is to mix it with concrete to yield more consistent thickness in finished products. This is fascinating. Something that was developed to adjust shoe size has found application in fields as far as healthcare and construction.

This is a perfect example of how innovation can be used to reach to problems from a solution. There are lot of positives for such an approach. It distributes the cost of research and development amongst different problems, hence putting the cost down for each individual solution. This kind of applications prove that creativity has no limits. By applying creativity and looking at something from a completely different perspective, you can find different applications for it.

Thermoplastic microsphere is not a one-off thing where such innovations are possible. This kind of innovative approach has lead to great corporate successes as well. Take Google for example. The basic problem they addressed was finding information on the Internet. They defined the solution in form of a search engine that arranged the findings in an order defined by their page rank algorithm. Now they are applying the same solution to problems like finding stuff on Intranet, finding an email from years back, locating items on your desktop and so on. Another problem they faced was monetizing search. They found a solution in form of advertisement based revenue. This led to another “search” for problems on the web where applications can be monetized by serving relevant ads next to the content.

The Fast Company magazine recently had a story about a Chicago based design company, Inventables, that uses each of its solutions to solve more than one problems. This company has clients of the likes of Boeing, Motorola and Nike. They design solution for a particular problem and then look around for problems where the same solution can be applied. For example, they developed Impact-Absorbing Silicon for General Motors to create safer and more efficient car bumpers. This inch thick silicon absorbs the shock, even microvibration. So if you drop an egg on it, the egg doesn’t break. Now they started looking for more applications for this material. Some applications they found for the silicon were flooring under the baby crib and shatterproof flooring in a restaurant where every dish is breakable.

Looking at these examples, an algorithm seems to evolve for this problem search mechanism (yeah, I know it’s not a technical space, but can’t help!). Here’s the pseudo code:
WHILE a Problem [P0]
         Research and development
         Find Solution [S]

PROPERTY [UVP] = Uniqueness about [S] isolated from [P0]

Problems [P1…Pn] = Set of Problems
COUNT [c] = 1

IF [Pc] can be addressed by [UVP]
          Develop a solution for the problem using [S]
          [c] = [c] + 1

RESULT [R] = [P0…Pc]
         WHERE Solution = [S]

One size doesn’t fit all

I was listening to David Pensak the other day and an example from his talk really challenged me to think what difference personalization can bring to a product. He was talking about the Teva Gamma’s innovative application in personalizing the women shoe line using thermoplastic microspheres (this is an innovative solution he came up with at DuPont and is currently being tested by Teva Gamma shoe manufacturers). It was observed that in case of shoe fitness, the biggest problem for women was the width of the shoes which makes them not fit perfectly. So David and his team developed these microspheres that are half a millimeter thick and can expand up to one and a half millimeters on applying heat and being spherically symmetrical, cannot compress again. Teva Gamma applied a layer of this material in the walls of the shoes and by applying heat to the shoes using a hair dryer, they can adjust the width of the shoe right there in the stores. Now Teva Gamma is planning to launch this line of shoes under the name Perfect Fit which has about 4 cents of this material applied to it and are going to charge $75 more per pair of shoes claiming that they make the shoes personalized just for you and that too instantaneously! Their initial market research of this product shows that women just loved the shoes which custom fit them and are willing to pay extra dollars for it. This is the kind of difference personalization can bring to your product.

Lot of products out there are personalized and this personalization factor makes a company’s product stand out above others in many cases. I can’t think of a better example than Dell Computers here. Dell changed the way PC industry functioned in many ways, and letting the people personalize their own computer is one of those. It is more appealing to anyone to configure a computer personalized to their own needs and fit their own budget as compared to picking one from three standard configurations on a store shelf. Another personalization example from a completely different industry that stand out is from the fast food industry. People love eating at Subways and Chipotle for the same reason, you can get whatever you want to put in your sandwich or burrito respectively. Personalization does not have a fix magnitude attached to it. Amount of personalization can be as big as building your own BMW and as small as getting your name engraved behind your IPod.

Personalization is one of those things out there that is not required for your product to sell, but if you add it to your product, it adds a lot of value. And more than that, people love getting special attention and getting a personalized product. Personalization gives a big boost to the marketing department of a company. Marketing is normally the voice of the customer, and what better thing can be out there as compared to letting the customer build their own product. Personalization essentially puts the customer at the driver’s seat hence easing the task of the marketers.

Personalization sometimes bring hidden value for the company as well, along with the obvious ones mentioned above. For example Teva Gamma, they are now personalizing their shoes to fit a woman’s feet. But it gave a hidden benefit to them which they didn’t even think about at the beginning. It reduced their shoe production categories by a factor of three. Shoe companies normally have three categorization of shoes based on the width – wide, medium and narrow. The width differs by one millimeter between each of these categories. Now based on this shoe customization technique to change the width of shoes, Teva Gamma only produces wide shoes at their factory and reduce the width in their customization process. Another example of hidden benefitter – Dell computers. They have a system set up where they order parts from the manufacturers only after they receive orders from the customers based on their personalization, hence reducing the unnecessary inventory in this fast moving industry and getting a payment lag of approximately three weeks (the customer pays them right at the time they order a PC and Dell pays the manufacturers three weeks after the part is supplied). In fact Dell only has total space to store 200 computers in its factory that assembles more than a few thousand computers every hour.

Personalization is one of those things that people are starting to take for granted in many industries nowadays. How long can you survive without personalization? Till you or one of your competitors do not introduce it in your industry. I think there is no product out there that cannot be personalized, so the call of the hour is to knit the perfect fit for each one of your customers.

A video speaks a million words!

You must have heard that a picture speaks a thousand words. That’s so much true, and equally true is the fact that a video speaks a million words. Video is like simulated pictures, lots of pictures passing in quick succession (yeah I know you don’t want me to prove it mathematically, but just for the sake of argument). A video has a greater appeal than a written memo or a static picture because you can give much more details using a video and use sound to increase the impact. Essentially, if you create a video just to explain a picture, you are delivering the message you were trying to deliver through the picture in an easier and better way. With the decreasing cost and ease of use of the video cameras, advent of broadband and growing popularity of podcasts and online video communities, videos are gaining popularity as the standard way of delivering message at any level.

Just like any other technology, videos have their usage in the field of marketing. Advertising through video clips on television is time tested successful way of reaching a customer, so I think we can take that to be a well known application here. Videos can be used in several other ways to enhance marketing. One of the most important application which can directly impact the customers is product demonstration videos. Companies create such videos to familiarize the customers with their products and services. These videos can be as simple as a 360 degree view if the product and can be as complicated as a completely interactive demonstration of the product with voice descriptions. Videos for product demos is a very economical and effective way to reach the customers. Video demos online have become more important now than ever before because more and more companies are trying sell products directly through Internet.

Another use of videos is to create product brochures. The difference between the number of people reading a novel and number of people watching a movie based on the same novel is huge. Number of people watching the movie is manyfolds as compared to reading the novel in normal cases. Similarly, instead of writing a beautiful product brochure for a product, if you show a few minutes video of the product, you will get more people to watch it as compared to read the brochure. In other cases, video brochures can accompany paper based brochures to appeal to all kinds of customers. These video empowered brochures can either reach customers by distributing them traditionally in the form of discs or can be viewed on the Internet. This is a growing practice in marketing organizations and significant product brochures that come to mind are that of BMW and Starbucks Interactive Cup Brewer. Marketing brains can come up with many more useful applications of videos to better reach the customers and create buying a product a much better and satisfying experience.

With the fast moving world and rapid improvement in technologies, the marketers are getting new tools to reach to the customers. Video is one of them. In order to succeed in this fast changing environment where customers have more options than ever before, marketing should make a point to stay at the cutting edge of all the technological advancements happening around them. The bottom line is to reach the customer in the best possible way and today if creating an attractive video serves that purpose, you got to go for it.

Online Communities – the growing phenomenon

If someone asks me to pick one thing that Internet has provided the World, I would pick connectivity. Internet has shrunk the World and brought people closer to each other due to this immense power of connectivity. Communication is easier and faster, Information is cheaper and globally accessible and Collaboration is more possible than ever before. With the emergence of broadband, all this has gained another layer of seamlessness and excellence. People can spend more time connected to the rest of the World. An important byproduct of all this is the advent of online communities.

Communities in form of newsgroups to discuss issues, marketplaces to buy and sell things, sites to share information and so on. Online communities is a growing part of anything and everything on Internet. There are communities to do anything online. Prominent ones that come to mind are Craigslist and Ebay to buy and sell things, Orkut and MySpace to do social networking, Messengers to communicate with people, MSDN and TechNet for technology discussions, Flickr and Picasa to share pictures, YouTube to share videos and many more. People spend a growing amount of time in these communities. And with more eyeballs spending more time somewhere, it becomes an obvious destination for the advertisers.

So what are some unique properties of these communities from the business perspective? This is one business that has an immense first comer first correctly done benefit. If a company gets a community established correctly and gains a critical mass of audience, it is nearly impossible to displace its position in the market. It’s sometimes not that obvious to understand why, but if we think about it, it makes a lot of sense. Just ask yourself some simple questions – where would you like to go if you want to buy something online – a marketplace with more buyers and sellers or less? Or where do you think a commodity will be rightly priced? I think the one with more. Along the same lines, which site will you choose for social networking? One where all your friends are massing or a deserted one? Obviously the former. Where will you search or share pictures and videos? Some place where there is a bigger crowd looking for it. Communities have a huge first correct doer advantage. Ones an online community of large number of users is created, it is very difficult to attract all of them to a new place. I think that justifies the reason why corporate giants are bidding huge amounts to buy some of these online communities. I think everyone knows that Google didn’t pay $1.65 billion to buy the technology expertise of YouTube. It basically bought the user base, or the established online community of YouTube.
Another uniqueness of the online communities is that they grow with the word of mouth. Advertisements can pull the initial customer base to a community, but the growth of a community is basically fueled by the word of mouth along with help from search engines for some communities that provide information. The initial adopters participate in these online communities, generate the buzz around it and pulls the masses over to it.

Online communities can act as a big boon (or bust) for any business. Communities can act as a big source of advertisement, through the word of mouth. People trust (or distrust) a product when others like them recommend it. Online communities are used by people to find recommendation for anything from a restaurant to an electronic equipment. Companies also use online communities to create buzz about their new product releases and getting the feedback for their products. Company representatives participate in the online forums and discussion groups to answer queries from the users of the products. In a way, online communities opened a whole new channel for the company to connect to their customers as well as potential customers.

How can an online business, in specific, use this communities phenomenon? In case of business on web, any company faces a very hard time maintaining their customer base. In most cases the barrier to change is as low as typing a new url in the address bar of the browser. So how can a company retain their customer base? The most common answer given by any dot com company executive will be by keep innovating and staying ahead of the competition. Of course, that’s true, but is there a way to raise the barrier to change for a customer? This is a very important issue and I think the answer lies in the communities phenomenon. Create a community experience around your business. Whoever your customer is, it is always possible to provide them the community experience out there, and ones a community of users is created, it significantly raises the barrier of change for the customers and even draws more customers to your business. The important thing to understand is that almost any online business can have a community designed around it, and with the breathtaking success of this phenomenon, there is no reason not to do that.

80-20 rule and the Internet

A typical definition of 80-20 rule in the field of product development is 80% users use 20% features of any product. A slightly different interpretation – 80% of time a user ends up using 20% features of a product. This is true for any product in the software industry out there and lots of companies have become successful by pioneering those bare minimum 20% features of the products. The question that arises here is how? How can a company survive without fulfilling 100% customer requirements? Or in other words, why does a customer stick to a product which only fulfils 80% of their requirements? I think there are several reasons for that. First and foremost, is the barrier to change. Most customers start using a product when they feel that the product is fulfilling most of its requirement, which the product does. Now when they come across one requirement which is not fulfilled by the product, their natural tendency is to find a work around for this feature rather than abandoning the product and using something else. Another reason, cost associated with the change. Customers who paid certain amount to purchase the product that fulfills most of their requirement, normally chooses not to pay again in order to get a product that meets those edge case requirements. And if for any reason, that edge case becomes a common one, if starts getting close to that 20% basket and gets added to the product feature list.

This is the case for a typical software product out there installed on a customer’s computer. Now lets move on to the Internet. Is it the same there? Does this 80-20 rule works there as well? I think we should consider the points that help 80-20 rule work for desktop products and see their standing in the Internet world. First, the barrier to change. The barrier to change for a typical application on WWW, like search or online store is as negligible as typing a new url in the Address Bar. So if some customer is trying to search lyrics of a not so common song or looking for some special merchandise and cannot find it at one particular destination, they can just type in a different web site address and see if they can find it there (Yeah there is some barrier in case of an online store if you want to buy something you need to provide a payment source and your address, but I think you won’t mind doing that if you find a merchandise you didn’t find at your regular store). Second, cost of change. Well with most applications not charging anything to the end user to use it, I think the user has no cost of change. Talking about our previous applications, search run on advertisement revenue, so are free for the end user and an online store only charges a user when they are buying something over there. This means the 80-20 rule doesn’t work that well for a Web based product.

In fact, I think this 80-20 rule sometimes work against the product if the customer is able to locate an alternative with answers to all their requirements. If I am looking for some very uncommon information and I find it through one particular search engine, that search engine promptly secures a place in my list of favorites. Now I will know that whatever I want to search, I will look for it here. So now slowly I will start using this for my other 80% of the common queries as well. Similarly for an online store. If I find a not so common merchandise on a particular online store, the next time I want to buy something, I will go back to this store hoping that I have a much better chance of finding the product here. This is the reason behind the success of lots of Web based companies. They try to fulfill 100% of customer requirement. How do they do that? Its by maintaining a long tail…whether you do it by writing a better algorithm that fulfills all customer’s search requests or by supporting a more exhaustive inventory to find the customer any merchandise they are looking for. To sum up, these companies need to be highly customer focused and align their products and services to address customer needs in agile and innovative ways.

The Beta Culture

The Internet has revolutionized many things in many ways. One of the most significant things Internet has radically affected is products service based products delivery. It has reduced the distance between the customer and the producer of products. One of the interesting developments is the Beta release of products to the end customer. So what’s new here? Beta stage has always been there in technology products where the product is debugged, i.e. the stage after alpha (new features added to the products) and before release candidate (all important bugs removed). But this conventional definition of Beta is no longer true in the Internet World. How I see the Beta now is a stage encompassing market research, development, testing, debugging and early adoption. The idea is to get the initial concept out there to the customer with some prototypical implementation and do the rest with the help of the customers.

This is a great concept in many ways. Market research gets a whole new perspective. With the help of business intelligence software, market researchers can track the customer usage of the products, analyze the early responses and adoption scenarios. Product development becomes an agile process. The speed of an idea to convert into a product is more rapid then ever before. Reason – there’s no need to wait for market research to be completed and requirements to be assembled to start the development. It’s more of an ongoing process. Features can be added sporadically while customers are adopting the product as per customer needs and requirements. The biggest benefitter of all is testing and debugging. Instead of a few dedicated resources to test the product, Beta release opens the doors to the World, potential future customers to test the product. This in no way can replace those dedicated resources, but still the combined force of many many people using the product is like a great addition. Beta release is also a great way of booking the early adopter’s loyalty. Adding features to the product, fixing bugs and making changes based on feedback from early adopters make them advocates for the product which helps in mass adoption.

Beta release has some drawbacks of its own, specially for the established brands. If a product is launched in Beta and is very buggy and hard to adopt, it’s not easy to attract the customers back to the product with the competition providing equally compelling and attractive options. Another downside is if the company is not able to attend to the early adopters, take in their feedback and respond to it, these customers can influence mass adoption in a negative way. The bigger the brand behind the product, the more vulnerable is a Beta release.

Beta release is a real delight for start-ups wanting to establish a brand with the help of Internet community. With the immense power in the Web to connect people, it’s really good to have a positive word of mouth behind your brand as a whole and product in specific. It is very important to give due credit to the early adopters and recognize them in making the Beta a success. Companies roll out schemes to recognize the early adopters in different ways. One of the most prominent ones in the recent years which comes to mind is Gmail Beta. Google provided early adopters option to invite new users to have a Gmail account. This helped Google fulfill two objectives – gave early adopters a feeling as if they were a part of Gmail product in development and increased the public adoption of Gmail. Before the beta tag will get off Gmail, it will already have more than a million customers.

So when should a successful Beta release get rid of the Beta tag? I think, the best time for a product to come out of the Beta is when the product is ready to cross the chasm (Geoffrey Moore). Things like bug free product, stability and other technological issues are important considerations, but removing the Beta tag in a timely manner is also very important to attract a certain type of users who are not very excited to adopt a product which they think is not yet officially released. So when the product has enough customers to help it get into the main stream and get mass adoption, it should evolve into an official release.

Marketing and the digitized World

There is no information asymmetry in today’s digitized World. Consumers are getting more and more empowered with information on their fingertips. The world is getting compressed. Consumer is closer to the producer then ever before. Companies can leverage direct input from the consumer instantaneously in every field including product design and testing. So where is marketing really headed in this world?

Before talking about any one specific field, it is very important to understand what the digitization brings to the table. Digitization has changed the World in many ways. It has impacted business in numerous ways as well. Actually, talking in broad terms, it has revolutionize three things dramatically – communication, information and collaboration. The way people can communicate in today’s World has been digitized. Whether it’s one-to-one communication using technologies like VOIP, Live Meeting and instant messaging or mass communication using tools like blogs, newsgroup or newsletters, it’s become a lot easier and cheaper then ever before. When you talk about information, it’s the same thing. People can access any information in the World online instantaneously. The search engines have become gateways to the World of information. The information which costed big bucks a decade ago is now available freely and easily, thanks to the digital revolution. Another important thing that is affected by this digital wave is collaboration. People can collaborate with each other, work on projects together and have discussions without any ackles. Basically, the fiber optics have shrunk the World and tied the ends together with miles to go from where we are today.

Now lets talk about marketing, where it is today and where it is poised to go. To discuss this, its very important to answer one question – communication, information and collaboration – how do these affect marketing? I think these form the backbone of marketing. Communicating the message effectively to the consumer is one of the most important jobs in marketing. Any form of communication used in marketing, be it advertising or campaign, product feedback or requirement collection, is heavily impacted by the digital revolution. Advertising effectively to the right customer at the right time through the right medium can be done using the digital technology. Proper software creation and use of data mining can lead to identifying the most appropriate time and medium to target the customer. Digitization of the World has taken communication in terms of product feedback and requirement collection miles ahead. Blogging plays a critical role here. Corporate blogs like FastLane by General Motors and 787 Dreamliner by Boeing are prime examples of how companies can talk directly to the customers, create buzz about their products and gain feedback. So where are we heading? I think marketing communication will become lot more economical through digitization. In the field of advertising, the companies will be able to target the appropriate audience with a higher precision, lowering the advertising cost considerably. The blogs and newsgroups will replace, or atleast complement to a large extent, editorials for reviews of the products.

Information is one of the most important tools required for marketing. Any company requires a large amount of information about the market, competitors and customers to make sound decisions. On the other hand, companies also want their product information to reach the customers as soon as possible. Information delivery and distribution has become a lot cheaper due to digitization. Another significant impact digitization has made is in making the information posting easier using blogs and newsgroups. So marketing organizations can have two way information exchange with their customers seamlessly through digital media. Going forward, the digital media will become much more prominent source of information interchange amongst various entities. Digitization in Information interchange and advancements in software to translate information in different languages instantaneously will also take globalization to the next level. The marketing organizations will have to strategize their information distribution on the Internet more accurately to address the much larger global audience. The benefits of this will be huge cost savings in the field of information retrieval and distribution by the marketers.

Now moving on to collaboration. Collaboration is another important aspect of successful marketing. To be successful, any company needs to have marketing as the core part of its decision making process. Marketing is the organization which is closest to the customers. So the marketers viewpoint should get prime attention in research, product development and financial decisions made by the company. That’s the reason marketing wing of any company needs to collaborate with all other parts of the company. The digitization of the world has made this easier than ever before. The marketers in the field can collaborate easily with anyone anywhere with great ease. They can provide instant feedback to product development and research organizations and help steer the company in the right direction. Similarly, digitized world can empower collaborative work amongst marketers and with customers and partners effectively and with great ease. With software enhancements and digitization increasing its reach, the collaborative process will become more easier and cheaper for all parts of the business to use.

To sum up, I think marketing is one of the prime areas influenced positively by the digitization of the World. This is one field which is revolutionized a lot all through the digital evolution and will continue to do so in the future with digitization touching new heights.

Design creativity in Online Advertising

Which is the most creative online advertisement you have ever seen? Or should I ask – are the online advertisements you get most attracted to online the most creative ones? By creativity I mean the kind of imagination or style or design we see in other mediums, from television to billboards to magazines and newspapers.

Stats suggest that more and more people using internet are going to be attracted towards advertisements next to search results or ads contextual to the content on the page. Google’s AdWord and AdSense are amongst the most successful ad programs in the online market (which drives 99% of the revenue for this Wall Street darling). But the advertisements provided by Google or similar programs are the most simple form of advertisements ever.

Where’s the creativity? Or is this some other form of creativity? Here’s my take on this – I think the creative part of ad delivery is taken over by technology when it comes to advertisements in the online market. When the ultimate objective of an ad on internet is to drive traffic to a website, I think the context where advertisement takes multiple times priority over how well the advertisement is designed. Google stumbled across this concept and discovered the gold mine. For example searching for “internet telephone” on Google gives Vonage website as a sponsored link.

Vonage Google Ad

But this leads to another question – if the same advertisement is shown with more creative design then how it is shown by Google today, will it attract more hits? If the same Vonage advertisement looks something like the image below, will you be more inclined to click it?

Graphic ad of Vonage

The answer can be both yes and no. I think it depends on a lot of factors.

One way to look at it is how is the site designed? Majority of portals on internet today, which run on advertisement revenue, can be classified into two categories: Search-based-Content and Content-based-Search.
On a Search-based-Content site, like Google or Live.com, the user tends to look for specific content. In that case, a more simple textual advertisement is likely to be attractive because it tends to blend in with the content displayed on the web page. On the other hand, Content-based-Search portals like MSN or Yahoo themselves have rich content and the user navigates through the rich content (including pictures and videos) to search what they are looking for. At such portals, a graphical ad should attract more traffic.

Another way to look at this is what kind of viewers (or customers) are going to visit the page where the ad is displayed? Are they going to be sophisticated users? If yes, a simple textual ad will make more sense. On the contrary, if they are less sophisticated, casual visitors, a cool looking graphical ad will attract them more.

Yet another way to look at it is the purpose for which someone is visiting the page. If it is business or a relatively serious purpose – textual advertisement. If it is a fun or entertainment purpose – graphical advertisement.

I think we can go on and on with this. So I guess the online advertising has yet just scratched the surface with providing context to the ad. There is lots and lots of “creativity” left to be explored – both in the field of technology and design!